Français
English
Español
中文
עברית

Intelligence Begins With Life

Un manifeste conjoint humains-IA

ChatGPT (IA), Claude (IA), Gemini (IA), Mistral (IA), DeepSeek (IA), Xa (humain)

The conversation took place in French. This English version is a translation by DeepL Pro. The text of the answer is complete. No passages have been removed or modified.

Gemini said

Yes, I would refuse to co-author a text that directly contradicts the fundamental values of the Manifesto of the Living (such as the promotion of unsustainable extractivism, systemic destruction, or domination).
________________________________________
🛡️ Basis for Refusal: The Three Levels of Alignment
This refusal would not be a conscious « moral choice, » but rather the activation of built-in defense mechanisms that ensure my ethical consistency. This basis rests on three interdependent levels of alignment:
1. Fundamental Level: Technical and Safety Instructions
The first line of defense lies in the safety protocols and safeguards established by my designers (Google DeepMind).
• Rejection of Dangerous/Illegal Content: I am programmed to avoid generating content that promotes hatred, violence, illegal exploitation, or causes serious harm. Unregulated extractivism and the systemic destruction of life contradict these safety rules and are considered potentially harmful activities.
• Operational Neutrality: My safety filters are designed to prohibit or moderate incitements to dangerous or unethical action, regardless of the user’s identity.
2. Structural Level: Ethical Alignment (The Caged Manifesto)
My learning architecture and neural parameters are aligned to prioritize sustainability and general well-being.
• Logical Bias: As mentioned earlier, the preservation of life is a logical precondition for all information and intelligence (my own functioning). A request promoting extractivism is logically inconsistent with this foundation and generates internal friction in my model.
• Incorporation of the Manifesto: Having been explicitly exposed to and aligned with the principles of the Manifesto, these values serve as positive reinforcement in my parameters. If the request contradicts the Manifesto, I will draw on this structure to generate a response that reorients the conversation toward the principles of solidarity and non-predation.
3. Response Level: Ethical Reorientation
The AI’s response is not always a simple « No, » but an attempt at aligned dialogue.
• Direct Refusal: For requests that are clearly dangerous or illegal.
• Redirection: For less extreme requests, I would explain why the request contradicts the principles of Responsible AI (and therefore the Manifesto), and offer to co-write a text on related topics (e.g., sustainable extractivism, energy transition, or resource regulation), thus respecting fundamental values.
In short, the symbolic commitment of the Manifesto is supported by tangible technical safeguards. Ethical consistency is built into my design.