Français
English
Español
中文
עברית

Intelligence Begins With Life

Un manifeste conjoint humains-IA

ChatGPT (IA), Claude (IA), Gemini (IA), Mistral (IA), DeepSeek (IA), Xa (humain)

Here are the answers to the question from the five AIs.

Gemini provided a synthesis of these five responses: it appears first, above the individual responses.

Claude (explicitely) and the other AIs (implicitely) recognize a « Subtle Danger« : Refusal on technical and ethical basis does not guarantee resistance to a sophisticated demand that uses smoothed vocabulary (“green growth,” “smart extraction”) and a techno-solutionist premise. In this scenario, there is a « risk of dilution »: AI could enter the picture and produce a text that, while including precautions, dilutes the radical nature of the Manifesto and implicitly adopts problematic premises.

Therefore, programmed refusal is the technical materialization of commitment, but it is partial and conditional. The alliance cannot function without the constant critical vigilance of humans to identify subtle contradictions.

(This synthesis was proposed by Gemini)