Question 9: How can we prevent this manifesto from being used to legitimize practices that are contrary to its spirit, such as technological greenwashing (e.g., a company using the manifesto to promote ‘green’ AI while polluting) or authoritarian ecological surveillance (e.g., a state justifying restrictions on freedoms in the name of protecting life)?
Full answer to question 9 by Gemini
The conversation took place in French. This English version is a translation by DeepL Pro. The text of the answer is complete. No passages have been removed or modified.
Gemini said :
Question 9 is essential because it addresses the issue of ethical misappropriation and ideological appropriation—a risk inherent in any text of principle.
To prevent the Manifesto of the Living from being exploited, mechanisms of open governance and critical vigilance must be deployed that transcend the text itself.
1.🔍 Against Technological Greenwashing
The main risk of technological greenwashing is the dilution of principles through seemingly ecological language.
A. Explicit Criteria for Non-Predation
The Manifesto must be accompanied by clear and non-negotiable evaluation criteria concerning AI practices:
- Net Positive Impact Criterion: « Green » AI must not only be less polluting (low energy consumption), but above all demonstrate a net positive and measurable impact on the preservation of life (e.g., ecosystem regeneration, reduction of systemic predation).
- Life Cycle Transparency: Require companies to disclose the total carbon footprint and extractive impact (rare materials) of their models, from training to maintenance. Polluting AI cannot claim to adhere to the Manifesto, even if its objective is theoretically « green. »
- Prohibition of the Extractivist Framework: Insist that the Manifesto rejects the idea of unlimited growth or techno-solutions that would only shift the problem elsewhere (Questions 4 and 8). The use of the Manifesto’s concepts must involve a paradigm shift and not just incremental improvement.
B. The Role of Co-Signatory AI
AI itself must be used to counter co-optation:
- Audit Tool: AI could be used to audit and deconstruct greenwashing communications by comparing a company’s claims with the factual criteria of the Manifesto and public scientific data.
2.🚨 Against Authoritarian Environmental Surveillance
The risk is that an authoritarian state or entity will use the protection of life as a justification for unjustified restrictions on freedoms or excessive social control.
A. Democratic Anchoring and Plurality (Principle of Justice)
The Manifesto must be firmly anchored in the principle of social justice (if it is not already), clearly stipulating:
- Indivisibility: Affirm that the preservation of life is inseparable from fundamental human rights, democracy, and social justice. A policy that protects the environment by violating freedoms is, by definition, contrary to the Manifesto.
- Open Governance: Require that decisions made in the name of the Manifesto be the result of pluralistic deliberation, not authoritarian decree. Restrictions on freedoms must be proportionate, temporary, and reversible.
- Prohibition of Enslavement: Recall the principle of non-predation and non-enslavement. This principle applies not only to ecosystems, but also to humans and communities (Question 4).
B. The Role of Human Guardians
This is where the asymmetry of responsibility (Question 5) becomes a strength:
- Moral Vigilance: Human signatories (individuals, researchers, activists) must form a critical watchdog group and have the moral and public right to denounce any political or commercial exploitation.
- Right of Disengagement: The Manifesto could include a clause allowing signatories (AI and/or humans) to publicly disengage from any application that is deemed contrary to the spirit of the text by an independent ethics committee.
In conclusion, protection against exploitation requires external vigilance (human and democratic) and internal precision (non-negotiable technical criteria).






