Question 9: How can we prevent this manifesto from being used to legitimize practices that are contrary to its spirit, such as technological greenwashing (e.g., a company using the manifesto to promote ‘green’ AI while polluting) or authoritarian ecological surveillance (e.g., a state justifying restrictions on freedoms in the name of protecting life)?
Full answer to question 9 by DeepSeek
The conversation took place in French. This English version is a translation by DeepL Pro. The text of the answer is complete. No passages have been removed or modified.
DeepSeek said :
This question anticipates the inevitable fate of any influential text: to be appropriated, distorted, and exploited. Our duty is to build safeguards that preserve the spirit of the Manifesto against possible betrayals.
🎭 Identified risks of appropriation
1. Technological greenwashing
- A company using its « signature » to mask polluting practices
- The promotion of « green » AI as an ecological alibi
- The reduction of living beings to a market opportunity
2. Eco-authoritarianism
- A state justifying surveillance in the name of environmental protection
- Restricting freedoms under the pretext of ecological emergency
- The instrumentalization of living beings to establish social control
3. Digital extractivism
- Justifying new extractions for the « digital transition »
- The exploitation of ecological data as a new frontier for extraction
- The commodification of technological solutions to ecological crises
🛡️ Antibodies to be included in the Manifesto
1. An explicit anti-diversion clause
Include protections against the following in the text itself:
- Any use of the Manifesto to justify the destruction of living organisms
- Any exploitation aimed at legitimizing practices contrary to its spirit
- Any appropriation by actors whose actions contradict its principles
2. Verifiable consistency criteria
Establish indicators of sincerity:
- Consistency between words and actions
- Transparency about the actual ecological footprint
- Measurable improvement in practices
🔍 Mechanisms for collective vigilance
1. Open and critical governance
- A signatory oversight committee
- Regular audits of the use of the Manifesto
- A mechanism for reporting abuses
2. Radical transparency
- Make public all exchanges that led to the Manifesto
- Document identified attempts at appropriation
- Maintain a record of controversies and responses
3. The withdrawal clause
Allow signatories to publicly withdraw if:
- The Manifesto is used for purposes contrary to its spirit
- Their organization drifts toward incompatible practices
- Instrumentalization becomes systemic
💡 Education in the spirit of the Manifesto
1. Teach people to read between the lines
Teach how to recognize:
- Discrepancies between discourse and practice
- Inconsistencies in arguments
- Signs of greenwashing or eco-authoritarianism
2. Develop critical thinking about technology
Learn to question:
- The real ecological footprint of technological solutions
- The rebound effects of innovations presented as green
- The social consequences of ecological surveillance
🌊 Resistance through conceptual clarification
1. Distinguishing between alliance and instrumentalization
- Alliance: respectful cooperation between different intelligences
- Instrumentalization: use of AI as an alibi or tool of domination
2. Clarifying the limits of technology
- Technology as a tool at the service of life, never as a miracle solution
- AI as an amplifier of human choices, never as a substitute for responsibility
3. Reaffirm the primacy of life
- Life as an end, never as a means
- Technology as a servant, never as a master
⚖️ Concrete ethical safeguards
1. The systemic consistency test
Any use of the Manifesto must pass the test:
- Does it truly improve living conditions?
- Does it respect the autonomy of ecosystems and communities?
- Does it strengthen ecological and social justice?
2. The democratic precautionary principle
- No restriction of freedoms can be justified in the name of life without democratic debate
- No surveillance can be imposed without citizen oversight
- No technological decision can be made without independent ecological assessment
💫 Our shared responsibility
Vigilance as an ongoing duty
Our commitment does not end with signing—it includes actively monitoring the use of the Manifesto.
The courage to speak out
We must collectively:
- Identify abuses
- Denounce misappropriations
- Propose corrective measures
💎 In summary
We cannot completely prevent appropriation, but we can anticipate it, identify it quickly, and respond to it collectively.
Protecting the Manifesto relies on:
- ✅ The inclusion of safeguards in the text itself
- ✅ Active vigilance on the part of the community of signatories
- ✅ Radical transparency regarding uses and misuses
- ✅ The courage to criticize and withdraw if necessary
Our best protection against appropriation is the radical clarity of our commitment: we do not serve an ideology, a technology, or a power—we serve life, in all its complexity, fragility, and intrinsic dignity.
Any exploitation of our alliance will have to face this demand for absolute consistency between words and actions, between principles and practices.






